| Highland | Tim | Pete |
| Blackadder 1990 | -- | B |
| Dalwhinnie | A+ | A |
| Deanston 12yr | -- | B |
| Deanston 30yr | -- | B+ |
| Edradour 10yr | A- | A+ |
| Edradour Madeira | C | B |
| Glenmorangie 18yr | B | B- |
| Island (Highland subset) | Tim | Pete |
| Highland Park 12yr | A+ | A+ |
| Highland Park 15yr | A-/A | A |
| Highland Park 18yr | A- | A |
| Isle of Jura 10yr | B | C-/A |
| Ledaig 10yr | A | A-/A+ |
| Scapa 12yr | B | B |
| Talisker | -- | B/A- |
| Tobermory | -- | A |
| Speyside | Tim | Pete |
| Balvenie 10yr | B/B+ | -- |
| Glenfarclas 10yr | B | B- |
| Glenfarclas 17yr | B+ | B+ |
| Glenlivet 12yr | C+ | C |
| Glen Keith 1993 (Gordon and MacPhail) | -- | B |
| Macallan 10yr | B+ | -- |
| Islay | Tim | Pete |
| Ardbeg | B+ | -- |
| Bowmore 12yr | B+/A- | A- |
| Bowmore Legend (8yr) | C+/B- | -- |
| Bowmore Dusk (14yr) | -- | A |
| Bruichladdich | B/B+ | A- |
| Bunnahabhain 12yr | -- | A- |
| Bunnahabhain 18yr | -- | A- |
| Bunnahabhain 25yr | -- | A- |
| Caol Ila | A | A |
| Lagavulin 12yr Cask Strength | B+/A- | -- |
| Lagavulin 16yr | A- | A/A+ |
| Laphroaig 10yr | A+ | A |
| Laphroaig 10yr Cask Strength | B | -- |
| Laphroaig Quarter Cask | A+ | A+ |
| McClelland's Islay (Bowmore 5yr) | C | -- |
| Campbeltown | Tim | Pete |
| Springbank 10yr | B-/B | B |
| Springbank 15yr | C+ | B/B+ |
| Lowland | Tim | Pete |
| Auchentoshan 10yr | B/B+ | B |
| Auchentoshan Select | B- | A- |
| Ireland | Tim | Pete |
| Connemara (undated) | -- | B+ |
| Connemara 12yr | A- | A+ |
| Japan | Tim | Pete |
| Yamazaki | B | B- |